Most loyalty schemes ask the customer to do the brand a favour: enrol, identify yourself at every purchase, hand over your data, and be repaid slowly, in a currency the brand invented, redeemable at a moment of the brand’s choosing. Response rates are low because that is a bad deal, not because the app needs redesigning.
The interesting question is not how to make the bargain more attractive. It is whether a reward has to be a bargain at all.
The offer, stated honestly
Write out what a conventional points scheme actually asks, and the problem becomes obvious.
- Sign up, which costs the customer a form and a password they will forget.
- Remember you are a member, at the till, on a bad day, in a queue.
- Accumulate value slowly, in units that are not money and whose exchange rate the brand can change.
- Wait, usually months, until enough has accrued to matter.
- Redeem, which almost always requires another purchase from the same brand.
Every step is work done by the customer for the brand’s benefit. The reward, when it finally arrives, is a discount conditional on spending more money. The customer is not being thanked, they are being invoiced with a coupon attached.
Set against that, the observed participation rates are not a mystery. They are an accurate valuation.
Three specific faults
It is deferred. The gap between the action and the reward is where motivation dies. Anything that pays out in three months is, psychologically, not a reward at all. It is a promise, and people discount promises heavily.
It is abstract. Points are not money and everyone knows it. A customer cannot tell you what 340 points is worth without looking it up, and the fact that the brand can devalue them at will is widely understood, even by people who would not put it in those words.
It is detached from the product. The scheme lives in an app, a card or an email, all of which are places the customer has to go on purpose. The product, meanwhile, is in their hand, on their shelf, in their kitchen. Loyalty schemes are almost always built in the one place the customer is not.
That third fault is the one worth fixing, because fixing it changes the other two on its own.
What changes when the reward is attached to the product
Put the identity on the item and the whole shape of the exchange inverts. The customer does not go to the scheme, the scheme is already in their hand. There is nothing to join, nothing to remember, nothing to carry and nothing to look up.
A concrete example, because this is an area where abstraction hides bad thinking.
A honey jar, refillable, with a tag in it. The customer takes it back to be refilled. They tap the jar and it tells them this is refill number eleven, how much carbon those eleven refills have saved against buying eleven new jars, and credits twenty pence towards the next one.
Look at what is not happening there.
The customer did not enrol. They were going to refill the jar regardless, because that is what the jar is for. Nobody asked them to identify themselves, because the jar already has an identity and they are holding it. The twenty pence is money, not points, and it arrives at the moment of the action rather than at the end of a quarter. The carbon figure is specific to this jar and this customer, so it is a fact about them rather than a marketing claim about the brand.
And crucially, the reward is a consequence of something the customer was doing anyway. Nobody has been persuaded to do anything.
Why that works when points do not
Immediate. The feedback arrives while the hand is still on the jar. There is no gap to lose interest in.
Concrete. Twenty pence is twenty pence, and refill number eleven is a number the customer can check against their own memory. Neither can be quietly devalued next quarter.
Unconditional in the right way. It is a credit against the thing they already return for, not a discount that only unlocks if they spend more.
It has a second reason to exist. The carbon saved is genuinely informative, so the interaction carries something beyond the money. Strip the twenty pence out and tapping the jar to see refill eleven and the carbon saved is still mildly interesting. Strip the discount out of a points scheme and nothing remains.
That last test is a good one to apply to any loyalty scheme you are considering. If you removed the financial incentive entirely, would anybody still use it? If the answer is no, you have not built loyalty, you have built a slow-release discount, and your competitors can match it by Friday.
What this is not
It is not a points programme with better branding. There is no accrued balance, no tier, no membership status and nothing being tracked that the customer has not chosen to make happen by using the product.
It is not an app. An app is another place you are asking the customer to go. The product is somewhere they already are.
It is not a discount strategy. The twenty pence is small on purpose. It is a marker of an action, and the interesting content sits next to it.
It is also not a universal answer. This shape works when the customer uses the product repeatedly, when there is a physical action worth recognising, and when the brand can honour a credit in a way that is not more trouble than it is worth. A one-off purchase with no repeat use has no equivalent moment to attach to, and pretending otherwise gets you a points scheme with a tag on it.
What it asks of you instead
Fewer things than a conventional loyalty scheme, but different things.
Item level identity. Not a product code, an individual one. The jar has to be that jar, or it cannot count its own refills.
A page you control. What the tag shows has to be changeable after the product is out in the world, or the eleventh refill shows the same thing as the first.
A way to honour the credit. This is the part people underestimate. Twenty pence has to be redeemable at the refill station, at the till or online without a staff member having to be trained in a new process. If honouring it is awkward, the scheme dies at the counter regardless of how elegant the tap was.
A reason to tap that is not the money. Refill count, carbon saved, provenance, where this batch came from, when it was made. The money brings them the first time. The content brings them back.
Where to start
One question, and it is not about technology.
What does your customer already do with your product that nobody currently notices?
Refilling it, servicing it, reselling it, using it up, bringing it back, passing it on. Those moments already exist and are already happening. A loyalty scheme that recognises one of them costs the customer nothing, because they have already paid the price of admission by using the thing they bought.
A loyalty scheme that asks for a new behaviour is asking for a favour, and it will be valued accordingly.
Veribli puts identity into products so that the product itself can recognise what the customer does with it, for brands from a Hull brewery to industrial circular supply chains. If you want to work out what your product could usefully notice, call us on 01482 455 855.
